After testing cabanas across five different cruise lines, I can tell you that Norwegian's Great Stirrup Cay accommodations are in a completely different league. While most cruise line cabanas are glorified beach umbrellas with a day bed, NCL's Silver Cove Villas and premium cabanas offer something revolutionary: actual indoor comfort with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and yes, real beds.
Here's the honest truth: most cruise cabanas are overpriced shade structures. I've rented them on Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay, Carnival's Half Moon Cay, and Princess Cays, and they're basically outdoor furniture with a roof. Norwegian took a completely different approach at Great Stirrup Cay.
Silver Cove Villas are the gold standard:
Pricing starts at $899 for a 1-bedroom Lagoon Villa, but here's the insider tip: that's per villa, not per person. Split among six people, you're paying about $150 each for luxury that rivals a resort.
I've spent thousands on cabanas across different cruise lines, so let me break down what you actually get for your money:
Norwegian's Premium Cabanas ($714 for up to 8 guests):
Royal Caribbean's Cabanas at Perfect Day ($449-699):
Carnival's Cabanas at Half Moon Cay ($389-589):
The difference is night and day. When it's 90°F and humid in the Bahamas, having actual air conditioning and a private bathroom isn't just luxury—it's necessity.
Most cruise lines treat cabanas as an afterthought—a way to squeeze extra revenue from their private islands. Norwegian built Great Stirrup Cay's accommodations as the main attraction. Here's what that means practically:
The Good:
The Reality Check:
Honestly? After experiencing Norwegian's setup, going back to a basic cabana feels like camping.
If you're convinced (and you should be), here's how to actually secure one of these villas:
Book immediately after your cruise confirmation. Silver Cove Villas sell out on popular itineraries within 48 hours of general booking opening. Don't wait.
Consider the 2-bedroom Oceanview Villa ($1,299) for larger groups. It accommodates up to 16 people, making the per-person cost incredibly reasonable for families or friend groups.
Pack strategically. Unlike regular beach days, you can store belongings securely and change clothes multiple times. Bring nice lunch attire since you'll have space to freshen up.
Don't overbook your day. The biggest mistake I see is people rushing off to zip-line or snorkel when they've paid premium prices for villa amenities. Plan to actually use what you're paying for.
Split costs wisely. The villa sleeps multiple people, but only book with people you're comfortable sharing close quarters with for 8+ hours.
Want to compare notes with other cruisers who've experienced Norwegian's villas? Share your Great Stirrup Cay experiences in our Private Islands forum!
At nearly double the cost of basic cabanas on other lines, Norwegian's villas require serious consideration. Here's my honest assessment after six visits:
Book a Silver Cove Villa if:
Skip it if:
The bottom line: Norwegian's Great Stirrup Cay accommodations have spoiled me for regular cruise cabanas. Yes, you'll pay more, but you're getting resort-level amenities instead of expensive beach furniture. For the right group and budget, it transforms your private island day from good to unforgettable.
Ready to experience Norwegian's premium island accommodations? Join the discussion and get booking tips from experienced cruisers in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum!
What Makes Norwegian's Great Stirrup Cay Different
Here's the honest truth: most cruise cabanas are overpriced shade structures. I've rented them on Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay, Carnival's Half Moon Cay, and Princess Cays, and they're basically outdoor furniture with a roof. Norwegian took a completely different approach at Great Stirrup Cay.
Silver Cove Villas are the gold standard:
- Full air conditioning throughout (not just fans like other lines)
- Private bedrooms with king-size beds in 1 and 2-bedroom villas
- Complete bathroom facilities with showers and toilets
- Living areas with flat-screen TVs and on-demand entertainment
- Private outdoor patios with premium lounge furniture
- Accommodates 6-16 guests depending on villa size
Pricing starts at $899 for a 1-bedroom Lagoon Villa, but here's the insider tip: that's per villa, not per person. Split among six people, you're paying about $150 each for luxury that rivals a resort.
The Cabana Comparison: NCL vs Everyone Else
I've spent thousands on cabanas across different cruise lines, so let me break down what you actually get for your money:
Norwegian's Premium Cabanas ($714 for up to 8 guests):
- Air-conditioned indoor space
- Private bathroom with shower
- Outdoor deck area
- Butler service
- Floating mats and water toys included
Royal Caribbean's Cabanas at Perfect Day ($449-699):
- Open-air structure with ceiling fans (no AC)
- No bathroom facilities
- Shared restrooms are a 3-minute walk away
- Food service available but limited
Carnival's Cabanas at Half Moon Cay ($389-589):
- Beach-side location with shade
- No air conditioning or bathroom
- Includes some snacks and beverages
- Decent furniture but very basic
The difference is night and day. When it's 90°F and humid in the Bahamas, having actual air conditioning and a private bathroom isn't just luxury—it's necessity.
Why Norwegian's Strategy Works (And Others Don't)
Most cruise lines treat cabanas as an afterthought—a way to squeeze extra revenue from their private islands. Norwegian built Great Stirrup Cay's accommodations as the main attraction. Here's what that means practically:
The Good:
- You can actually nap comfortably in air conditioning
- Changing clothes and freshening up is private and convenient
- Bad weather doesn't ruin your expensive day
- Multi-generational families have space to spread out
- Butler service means you're not making constant trips to bars
The Reality Check:
- You'll pay 40-60% more than other cruise line cabanas
- Popular sailing dates sell out months in advance
- The island can feel crowded around Silver Cove area
- You might spend so much time in your villa you miss the beach
Honestly? After experiencing Norwegian's setup, going back to a basic cabana feels like camping.
Booking Strategy and Insider Tips
If you're convinced (and you should be), here's how to actually secure one of these villas:
Book immediately after your cruise confirmation. Silver Cove Villas sell out on popular itineraries within 48 hours of general booking opening. Don't wait.
Consider the 2-bedroom Oceanview Villa ($1,299) for larger groups. It accommodates up to 16 people, making the per-person cost incredibly reasonable for families or friend groups.
Pack strategically. Unlike regular beach days, you can store belongings securely and change clothes multiple times. Bring nice lunch attire since you'll have space to freshen up.
Don't overbook your day. The biggest mistake I see is people rushing off to zip-line or snorkel when they've paid premium prices for villa amenities. Plan to actually use what you're paying for.
Split costs wisely. The villa sleeps multiple people, but only book with people you're comfortable sharing close quarters with for 8+ hours.
Want to compare notes with other cruisers who've experienced Norwegian's villas? Share your Great Stirrup Cay experiences in our Private Islands forum!
Is It Worth the Premium Price?
At nearly double the cost of basic cabanas on other lines, Norwegian's villas require serious consideration. Here's my honest assessment after six visits:
Book a Silver Cove Villa if:
- You're traveling with 6+ people who can split costs
- You value comfort over adventure activities
- Someone in your group has mobility issues (the AC and bathroom access are game-changers)
- You're celebrating a special occasion
- You've done the "basic beach day" thing and want an upgrade
Skip it if:
- You prefer exploring the entire island
- You're comfortable with shared beach facilities
- Your budget is tight (regular beach access is included in your cruise)
- You're traveling solo or as a couple (the value proposition doesn't work)
The bottom line: Norwegian's Great Stirrup Cay accommodations have spoiled me for regular cruise cabanas. Yes, you'll pay more, but you're getting resort-level amenities instead of expensive beach furniture. For the right group and budget, it transforms your private island day from good to unforgettable.
Ready to experience Norwegian's premium island accommodations? Join the discussion and get booking tips from experienced cruisers in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum!
Last edited: