After visiting Great Stirrup Cay six times over the past decade, I can tell you this isn't the same private island it was even two years ago. Norwegian's massive investment has transformed their 268-acre Bahamian paradise into something that rivals the best resort destinations – and honestly, it's now my favorite private island experience.
But here's what you need to know: the changes aren't just cosmetic upgrades. From beverage package restrictions to new pier operations, Great Stirrup Cay operates differently now. Let me walk you through everything that's changed, what's stayed the same, and how to make the most of your day here.
The biggest transformation? No more tender boats. The new $50 million pier means you walk directly off ships like Norwegian Breakaway and Norwegian Encore onto the island. I've done the tender shuffle too many times to count, and this change alone makes Great Stirrup Cay infinitely more enjoyable.
But the real showstopper is Great Life Lagoon – a 1.4-acre heated pool complex that cost $35 million. When I say heated, I mean it stays at 84°F year-round, which is perfect during those cooler January and February sailings. The two swim-up bars here (Lagoon Bar East and West) serve everything from frozen cocktails to light lunch items.
The Vibe Shore Club is Norwegian's answer to adults-only luxury, and at $79 per person, it's actually reasonable compared to similar experiences. You get exclusive beach access, premium cabanas with AC, and a dedicated bar serving top-shelf liquor. I spent a full day here during my March 2026 visit, and the service was resort-level quality.
Coming this summer: Great Tides Waterpark will be massive – 19 waterslides across six acres. The 170-foot Tidal Tower will be visible from miles away, and that 800-foot river with the bioluminescent tunnel sounds incredible (though I haven't experienced it yet).
Want to discuss these upgrades with other cruisers? Check out our Caribbean Ports forum for real-time reports from recent visitors!
Here's something most guides won't tell you: beach location matters more than you think. I've learned this through trial and error across multiple visits.
Infinity Beach is closest to the main dining areas (Jumbey Beach Grill and Abaco Taco), making it convenient for families with kids who need frequent snack breaks. But it's also the most crowded. Get off the ship in the first wave if you want prime real estate here.
Lighthouse Beach offers the best combination of space and atmosphere. The historic 1863 lighthouse provides natural shade, and you're still within reasonable walking distance of food. This is where I always head now.
Silver Cove Beach is exclusive to villa guests, and honestly, the $899+ daily rate for a Lagoon Villa might be worth it if you're traveling with a larger group. The beach here is pristine, and the service is exceptional.
Pro tip from my February 2026 visit: the beaches on the western side get afternoon shade from palm trees, while eastern beaches stay sunny all day. Plan accordingly based on your sun tolerance.
Here's the change that caught everyone off guard: starting March 1, 2026, standard Free at Sea beverage packages no longer work on Great Stirrup Cay. Only Free at Sea Plus (which costs an additional $49.99 per day) includes island drinks.
This means a couple with the standard package faces an extra $100 per day just for drinks on the island. Individual cocktails run $12-15, beers are $6-8, and even bottled water costs $4. If you're planning multiple drinks, the Plus upgrade pays for itself quickly.
I learned this the hard way during my April sailing – my standard package worked fine on the ship but was declined at every island bar. The crew wasn't fully informed about the change either, leading to confusion and long lines.
Alternative: bring a reusable water bottle (fill it on the ship) and limit island drinking to special occasions.
All food is complimentary from 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM, but the quality varies significantly by location.
Jumbey Beach Grill serves the classics – hamburgers, hot dogs, BBQ chicken, and various salads. The jerk chicken is surprisingly good, but avoid the fish unless it's clearly fresh (check how busy the station is).
Abaco Taco Shack became my go-to after discovering their fish tacos. The beef and chicken options are standard cruise fare, but the fresh salsas and toppings make them worthwhile.
Tropic Like It's Hot Food Truck offers lighter fare – think wraps, sandwiches, and fruit. Perfect for a quick lunch without the buffet crowds.
Insider tip: the ice cream stations scattered around the island serve the same premium brands as on the ship. Free soft-serve beats paying $5 for a popsicle at most beach destinations.
Share your favorite Great Stirrup Cay dining spots in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum!
I've booked cabanas three times at Great Stirrup Cay, and here's my honest assessment:
Premier Cabanas ($449 for up to 8 guests) include refrigerated drinks, fresh fruit, and dedicated service. The air conditioning alone is worth it during summer sailings when temperatures hit 90°F+ with high humidity.
Classic Cabanas ($425 for up to 6 guests) offer the same comfort without AC. Fine for winter visits, but I wouldn't book these June through September.
The real luxury experience is Silver Cove villas. The 1-Bedroom Villa sleeps 10 for around $899, which breaks down to $90 per person – reasonable for a premium beach club experience anywhere else. The private beach, infinity pool, and champagne bar create a genuinely upscale atmosphere.
However, book early. Cabanas sell out quickly, especially during peak season (December through March).
After trying most of Great Stirrup Cay's paid activities, here's what's worth your money:
Zip Line ($108+ adults): The views are spectacular, but it's over quickly. Worth it if you're an adrenaline junkie, skippable otherwise.
Swimming with Pigs Excursion (~$150 adults/$110 kids): This takes you to nearby Pig Beach, and it's genuinely magical. The pigs swim out to your boat, and photo opportunities are endless. Book this.
Jet Ski Tours: Prices vary by season, but expect $120+ for 30 minutes. Fun but expensive for what you get.
Parasailing: Only available during summer months and weather permitting. When available, it's around $85 for single riders.
Free activities like snorkeling, volleyball, and hammock lounging honestly provide 90% of the island experience. The protected coves have decent marine life, and the artificial reefs are worth exploring.
I've visited Great Stirrup Cay in every season, and timing matters more than most people realize.
December through April: Perfect weather (75-82°F), minimal rain, but also peak season pricing and crowds. Book activities early.
May through July: Hot (85-93°F) but manageable with ocean breezes. Occasional afternoon showers that cool things down.
August through November: Hurricane season brings uncertainty. I've had two visits cancelled due to weather, so consider trip insurance.
The island has excellent drainage from recent infrastructure improvements, so brief tropical showers don't ruin beach days like they used to.
After six Great Stirrup Cay visits, these details matter:
Seventeen NCL ships include Great Stirrup Cay on their itineraries, including the brand-new Norwegian Luna (debuting March 2026). Most Bahamas and Western Caribbean cruises from Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and Port Canaveral stop here.
The larger ships (Norwegian Breakaway, Norwegian Encore) benefit most from the new pier – no more 45-minute tender waits with 4,000+ passengers.
After experiencing the 2026 upgrades firsthand, Great Stirrup Cay has evolved from a "nice beach day" into a legitimate resort destination. The heated lagoon, improved dining, and pier access address every complaint I had about the old version.
Yes, the beverage package changes are frustrating, and premium experiences cost extra. But compared to similar private islands, Great Stirrup Cay offers better value and less commercialization than some competitors.
For families, the upcoming waterpark will be game-changing. For adults seeking luxury, Silver Cove delivers. And for budget-conscious cruisers, the free beach experience remains excellent.
Ready to plan your Great Stirrup Cay visit? Join the discussion and get real-time updates from recent visitors in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum – our community shares the latest tips, photos, and insider information you won't find anywhere else!
But here's what you need to know: the changes aren't just cosmetic upgrades. From beverage package restrictions to new pier operations, Great Stirrup Cay operates differently now. Let me walk you through everything that's changed, what's stayed the same, and how to make the most of your day here.
The Game-Changing 2026 Upgrades
The biggest transformation? No more tender boats. The new $50 million pier means you walk directly off ships like Norwegian Breakaway and Norwegian Encore onto the island. I've done the tender shuffle too many times to count, and this change alone makes Great Stirrup Cay infinitely more enjoyable.
But the real showstopper is Great Life Lagoon – a 1.4-acre heated pool complex that cost $35 million. When I say heated, I mean it stays at 84°F year-round, which is perfect during those cooler January and February sailings. The two swim-up bars here (Lagoon Bar East and West) serve everything from frozen cocktails to light lunch items.
The Vibe Shore Club is Norwegian's answer to adults-only luxury, and at $79 per person, it's actually reasonable compared to similar experiences. You get exclusive beach access, premium cabanas with AC, and a dedicated bar serving top-shelf liquor. I spent a full day here during my March 2026 visit, and the service was resort-level quality.
Coming this summer: Great Tides Waterpark will be massive – 19 waterslides across six acres. The 170-foot Tidal Tower will be visible from miles away, and that 800-foot river with the bioluminescent tunnel sounds incredible (though I haven't experienced it yet).
Want to discuss these upgrades with other cruisers? Check out our Caribbean Ports forum for real-time reports from recent visitors!
Beach Strategy: Where to Set Up Camp
Here's something most guides won't tell you: beach location matters more than you think. I've learned this through trial and error across multiple visits.
Infinity Beach is closest to the main dining areas (Jumbey Beach Grill and Abaco Taco), making it convenient for families with kids who need frequent snack breaks. But it's also the most crowded. Get off the ship in the first wave if you want prime real estate here.
Lighthouse Beach offers the best combination of space and atmosphere. The historic 1863 lighthouse provides natural shade, and you're still within reasonable walking distance of food. This is where I always head now.
Silver Cove Beach is exclusive to villa guests, and honestly, the $899+ daily rate for a Lagoon Villa might be worth it if you're traveling with a larger group. The beach here is pristine, and the service is exceptional.
Pro tip from my February 2026 visit: the beaches on the western side get afternoon shade from palm trees, while eastern beaches stay sunny all day. Plan accordingly based on your sun tolerance.
The Beverage Package Bombshell (Critical Update)
Here's the change that caught everyone off guard: starting March 1, 2026, standard Free at Sea beverage packages no longer work on Great Stirrup Cay. Only Free at Sea Plus (which costs an additional $49.99 per day) includes island drinks.
This means a couple with the standard package faces an extra $100 per day just for drinks on the island. Individual cocktails run $12-15, beers are $6-8, and even bottled water costs $4. If you're planning multiple drinks, the Plus upgrade pays for itself quickly.
I learned this the hard way during my April sailing – my standard package worked fine on the ship but was declined at every island bar. The crew wasn't fully informed about the change either, leading to confusion and long lines.
Alternative: bring a reusable water bottle (fill it on the ship) and limit island drinking to special occasions.
Dining Deep Dive: Beyond the Basics
All food is complimentary from 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM, but the quality varies significantly by location.
Jumbey Beach Grill serves the classics – hamburgers, hot dogs, BBQ chicken, and various salads. The jerk chicken is surprisingly good, but avoid the fish unless it's clearly fresh (check how busy the station is).
Abaco Taco Shack became my go-to after discovering their fish tacos. The beef and chicken options are standard cruise fare, but the fresh salsas and toppings make them worthwhile.
Tropic Like It's Hot Food Truck offers lighter fare – think wraps, sandwiches, and fruit. Perfect for a quick lunch without the buffet crowds.
Insider tip: the ice cream stations scattered around the island serve the same premium brands as on the ship. Free soft-serve beats paying $5 for a popsicle at most beach destinations.
Share your favorite Great Stirrup Cay dining spots in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum!
Cabana Reality Check: Worth the Splurge?
I've booked cabanas three times at Great Stirrup Cay, and here's my honest assessment:
Premier Cabanas ($449 for up to 8 guests) include refrigerated drinks, fresh fruit, and dedicated service. The air conditioning alone is worth it during summer sailings when temperatures hit 90°F+ with high humidity.
Classic Cabanas ($425 for up to 6 guests) offer the same comfort without AC. Fine for winter visits, but I wouldn't book these June through September.
The real luxury experience is Silver Cove villas. The 1-Bedroom Villa sleeps 10 for around $899, which breaks down to $90 per person – reasonable for a premium beach club experience anywhere else. The private beach, infinity pool, and champagne bar create a genuinely upscale atmosphere.
However, book early. Cabanas sell out quickly, especially during peak season (December through March).
Activity Pricing and Honest Reviews
After trying most of Great Stirrup Cay's paid activities, here's what's worth your money:
Zip Line ($108+ adults): The views are spectacular, but it's over quickly. Worth it if you're an adrenaline junkie, skippable otherwise.
Swimming with Pigs Excursion (~$150 adults/$110 kids): This takes you to nearby Pig Beach, and it's genuinely magical. The pigs swim out to your boat, and photo opportunities are endless. Book this.
Jet Ski Tours: Prices vary by season, but expect $120+ for 30 minutes. Fun but expensive for what you get.
Parasailing: Only available during summer months and weather permitting. When available, it's around $85 for single riders.
Free activities like snorkeling, volleyball, and hammock lounging honestly provide 90% of the island experience. The protected coves have decent marine life, and the artificial reefs are worth exploring.
Weather and Seasonal Considerations
I've visited Great Stirrup Cay in every season, and timing matters more than most people realize.
December through April: Perfect weather (75-82°F), minimal rain, but also peak season pricing and crowds. Book activities early.
May through July: Hot (85-93°F) but manageable with ocean breezes. Occasional afternoon showers that cool things down.
August through November: Hurricane season brings uncertainty. I've had two visits cancelled due to weather, so consider trip insurance.
The island has excellent drainage from recent infrastructure improvements, so brief tropical showers don't ruin beach days like they used to.
Practical Tips from 40+ Cruises
After six Great Stirrup Cay visits, these details matter:
- Bring ship towels – island towel service ended in 2025
- Water shoes are essential; the sandy bottom has occasional rocks and coral pieces
- No WiFi on the island (cell service is spotty) – perfect for unplugging
- Sunscreen must be reef-safe – they're serious about environmental protection
- Everything charges to your cruise card; no cash needed except for local vendors
- The last tender traditionally left at 4:30 PM, but with the new pier, departure times are more flexible
Which Ships Visit in 2026
Seventeen NCL ships include Great Stirrup Cay on their itineraries, including the brand-new Norwegian Luna (debuting March 2026). Most Bahamas and Western Caribbean cruises from Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and Port Canaveral stop here.
The larger ships (Norwegian Breakaway, Norwegian Encore) benefit most from the new pier – no more 45-minute tender waits with 4,000+ passengers.
Bottom Line: Is Great Stirrup Cay Worth the Hype?
After experiencing the 2026 upgrades firsthand, Great Stirrup Cay has evolved from a "nice beach day" into a legitimate resort destination. The heated lagoon, improved dining, and pier access address every complaint I had about the old version.
Yes, the beverage package changes are frustrating, and premium experiences cost extra. But compared to similar private islands, Great Stirrup Cay offers better value and less commercialization than some competitors.
For families, the upcoming waterpark will be game-changing. For adults seeking luxury, Silver Cove delivers. And for budget-conscious cruisers, the free beach experience remains excellent.
Ready to plan your Great Stirrup Cay visit? Join the discussion and get real-time updates from recent visitors in our Norwegian Cruise Line forum – our community shares the latest tips, photos, and insider information you won't find anywhere else!
Last edited: